The Polynesian

Cocktails are great

Visited The Polynesian over the weekend late on a Sunday afternoon. There were people there but it wasn't packed, no trouble getting a table. This place has a lot of great things going for it; Drinks: top notch (I had the Tangaroa followed by The Derelict both amazing). Tiki mugs: unique and impressive. There were also some nice touches like the napkins and the drink umbrellas with The Polynesian logo printed on them. Menu also designed with nod to the artwork of vintage Tiki menus. Where the whole thing falls short, as others here have mentioned is the overall design/experience. It is not designed as a tiki bar but more of another upscale NYC bar that caters to the millenial nightlife crowd. The music was a mix of classic rock and hip hop which I didn't totally mind but I didn't feel this was the venue for it. In fact I didn't hear any exotica, Hawaiian or surf tunes. With all that said, I'll probably return for a repeat visit with a friend so they can see how amazing the drinks are, but after that I'm not so sure this will be a go-to in the foreseeable future.

I have been to the Polynesian several times since it opened already, and I am overall very impressed with the place. New York tends to have major issues being Tiki, they feel they must have some sort of twist on it or a modernization. grand opening night I arrived in full Hawaiian regalia, white pants white loafers vintage aloha shirt and straw hat, and I was one of only a few people who were remotely dressed for it. That night I sat at the bar and enjoyed a few too many concoctions starting with some from the menu and of course asking for a Mai Tai, which oddly is not on the menu, nor is any classic Tiki drink except for a frozen pina colada. Every drink is a original, they are great, however there should be a classic section. They do make up for it by having bartenders who know what to do as my might I was gorgeously tasty. That night the music was a lovely mix of retro Hawaiian, surf, ska, and reggae, which really reflected the atmosphere I think.
However, on subsequent visits, it appears the playlist is being slowly tweaked away from the traditional and more towards generic oldies and classic rock. I feel this is kowtowing to the douchey after work crowd that loves the outdoor space, and order beers and vodka tonics. There seem to be more and more of them with each visit. the only way I can see to avoid them is to come later at night, when it's slower and you can chat with the bartender and get some real good drinks. In spite of these things it is still one of the best in the city. If they can just keep in mind that this should an immersive experience, they it could be the best overall.

Great drinks and location. Above a rooftop overlooking as somewhat near Times Square, the drinks are up there, but so are the prices. The food I would pass on... eat before you come. Bar snacks are fine, but overpriced. The mugs are off the hook, way above the ordinary, Its modern interpretation of tiki for sure but they nail it. You soon forget you are in Midtown Manhattan in a 100F heatwave and think you are in a tropical bar. As for the music, everything from 50s Oldies, Motown, even some 70s & 80s Music in there. Worth the trip if you have the budget, especially since its literally only 1 of maybe 3 "real" tiki places in NYC.

Outstanding drinks and excellent service. More Polynesian than Tiki in decor, but drinks are tiki. Food is small portions, delicious, but ridiculously overpriced.

Looking forward to the mugs going on sale.

I went to The Polynesian with open mind because I am not particularly fond of modern very light and bright inside Tiki establishments. I prefer dark such as the Mai-Kai and Frankies Tiki Room. The first visit was on Sunday because I didn't want to deal with crowds, I was impressed with the drinks. Second visit on weekday was crowded but still impressed and accepted the light modern Tiki atmosphere.
Seems like a lot of NYC after work business clientele. On both visits I was the only one with an Aloha shirt except for the bartenders and staff:(

We enjoyed our visit to The Polynesian.
Get the Vaya Kon Tiki. TRUST ME!
They do have signature mugs but were not selling them when we went.
Feels like a upscale hotel tiki bar. Skip the food and come for the liquid paradise.
OH and the mixologist wear Hawaiian shirts and sarongs which I thought was different.

My immediate takeaway from The Polynesian is it reminds me a lot of Milwaukee's The Love Shack, but with more towards a bend towards classic. The vibe of the place felt very much like the type of place in '50s or '60s New York City where a tired businessman would take his wife or mistress to get away from the city. They even have hostesses and greeters in dresses covered in tropical flowers, which feelsl like a modern spin on waitresses in coconut bras and grass skirts. It's a vibe I'm totally okay with.

I don't think it's a tiki bar. It feels like a bar with heavy Polynesian influences, but I saw very few tikis at this bar. It's also way too light, although I went while it was still light out, but I've been to plenty of tiki bars where they're very dark and mysterious at 4 p.m. in June. This is New York. We're really comfortable with very dark bars and restaurants. I will give them credit for playing some traditional Hawaiian music, although they also played reggae and Bossa Nova.

There was no Mai Tai on the menu, but they did have a pretty decent selection of drinks. They also had standard bar drinks, like a rum and Coke with a fancy name, but at least they admitted it was really just a rum and Coke. The Tangaroa was delicious and I loved the mug it came in. It felt like actual carved stone instead of standard ceramic. This also seemed to be the best value for how much liquid I got with my drink, to the point I was stunned there was still liquor in my mug for me to drink, so that does make the prices a lot more justifiable. The Vaya Kon Tiki will likely be the drink that is the most Instagrammed since they light a fire on top, although I did gasp with joy at the sight of a shared drink that looks like it's served in a giant shell. I will also give them props for having alcohol-free drinks because not a lot of bars have those options, period, and it does make it more enjoyable for everyone.

As for the food, they are more on the (very pricey) snack side, but the tuna poke was very tasty. I did see a table that ordered the Polynesian Pupu Platter and I was in awe of the wooden tri-tiered serving set-up, with a pineapple on top. The calamari smelled delicious from where I was seated. The crowd was mostly Midtown Businessmen and some tourists, but it was fairly calm in there and I was able to easily hear the music, take notes, and read a book while enjoying my drink and eating poke.

I don't think it's a good tiki bar, but I do think it's a great Polynesian restaurant and bar and of the tiki bars in New York City, it's the one I would go to again.

It's open and airy, not dark at all, but I don't think that draws away from the Tikiness. It's HUGE by NYC standards. The drinks were all top notch, and I'd suggest people try the menu items before asking for the old stand bys. I didn't notice music and didn't try the food, but I'll be back soon for another experience.

I visited on 6/10/18 on a Sunday evening and the bar was lively, but definitely not packed. The decor is Polynesian modern at best with hardly any Tiki to speak of. The three rooms and outdoor seating area are massive and I can't imagine this place getting packed on the regular.

The drinks were the best part. Our group of three ordered seven or eight different libations and all were excellent. Food was also tasty, albeit more tapas style than a proper meal, which is odd considering how much room their is for full dinner service.

The music started off solid, with a mix of Elvis and surf tunes, but it went south as the evening progressed. That said, the vibe was fun and the atmosphere was enjoyable enough that I would definitely go back. The worst part was that the place has its own series of mugs by Tiki Diablo and Tiki Farm, but refuses to sell them because they are for drinking. I'm not sure how smart it is to have $100 Tiki Diablo mugs for regular service, but after pleading with the stiff manager in the un-Tiki jacket for half an hour, I gave up and went back to my drink.

Upscale modern lounge with Polynesian influences. Beautiful outdoor space, which is uncommon for the city. Tiki drinks are top-notch, but I feel like i'm in a high-end hotel lounge, not a Tiki bar.

This is a lovely hotel bar with a light semi-tropical decor overlay that inexplicable serves wonderful tiki drinks in lovely tiki mugs. It will easily re-theme to Asian Fusion once they are over tiki drinks.

The drink menu is classic tiki - including the fact that they have slightly tweaked classic drinks and re-named them (aka The Double Winchester aka Gun Club Punch). The drunks are A+ but they would taste so much better in a dark bar rather than a classy tasteful expensive hotel bar.

The place is pretty huge by city standards, and has a nice outdoor space with its own bar. Seems very popular with a midtown financier kind of crowd.