Shipwreck Tavern

Bayville, NY
Bar & Restaurant
I want to go!
Plan your visit:
Get there
I have been!
Report back to Critiki:
Add Pics
10 Bayville Ave
Bayville, NY
Opened in 2006
Mon-Thu noon-10pm
Fri-Sat noon-11pm
Sun noon-9pm
(516) 628-2628

Critiki ratings

Shipwreck Tavern



by 4 people



Everyone You
Decor 7
Drink Quality 6.3
Drink Selection 7
Food Quality 8
Food Selection 6
Mood 5.9
Music 6.7
Service 9
Tikiness 6
Tilt 6
Vibe 6

Upcoming Visits

Regulars & Visitors

View all 7 Shipwreck Tavern regulars & visitors

Humuhumu’s description

Shipwreck Tavern is a nautically-themed restaurant that opened in the fall of 2006. In summer 2007, they added a "Tiki Bar and Cafe" that includes an outdoor seating area with tiki poles and masks. Shipwreck Tavern is owned and operated by the same outfit that owns the pirate-themed Bayville Adventure Park next door, and also the Jekyll & Hyde Club in New York City.


NatalievonTiki has visited Shipwreck Tavern.
April 6, 2017, 12:13 PM
I went one time during the off-season so it was really dead inside. The food was good, but more typically pub food. The decor is ok, not overly tiki. Staff was friendly and helpful. My favorite part was the giant fish tank with a very friendly puffer fish who seemed to like to swim past us every two minutes.
It is a bit off the beaten path, so I wouldn't rush back unless I was in the area.
October 4, 2008, 12:44 PM
The Shipwreck Tavern has two tiki bars: one outside the restaurant entrance and the other on the roof of the Tavern building, accessible via an exterior stairway. The Tavern interior is maritime themed, with models of tall ships, figureheads, a large fish aquarium, and so forth; all of the tiki is outside and thus presumably seasonal. Both tiki bars feature thatched huts, tiki posts linked by net fencing, and bamboo landscape edging. Children under 13 aren't allowed in the rooftop area, perhaps because the staff worries about them toppling over the net fencing to the pavement below.

The food is American with nothing exotic beyond the merest nod to Asia (e.g., eggroll appetizers). They do offer a wide selection of beers both draught and bottled, though the afternoon I went the bar seemed on the edge of implosion: the taps were broken and the place was under assault from a swarm of yellowjackets, so much so that my sister-in-law twice ordered pina coladas and twice received them with exoskeletal garnishes. Disgusting, certainly, but I would like to think the Tavern was having an isolated bad day.

There are two things to recommend the Tavern's tiki bars: the adjacent Bayville Adventure Park (also O&Oed by the Jekyll & Hyde Entertainment Group) and the public beach directly to the north. You could do worse than baking on the shore of Long Island Sound before flip-flopping across the street to sip Zombies under the thatch.
Upcoming Visits
Regulars & Visitors
  • Von_Kraut
  • PAPA-OOM-Moai-Moai
  • internalnoise
  • A'Pau-ling
  • timeinhell
  • NatalievonTiki
  • Ocean Flo
View all 7 Shipwreck Tavern regulars & visitors